Some Stray Thoughts on Osama’s End

By Saeed Qureshi   

A decade long manhunt for Osama finally came to a close on the night of May 2 when America’s toughest counter terrorism force Navy Seals nabbed and killed the chief of al-Qaida in a house located in Abbottabad, a scenic city barely 60 miles by road from the capital of Pakistan, Islamabad.

If ISI had been abetting Osama then they would not have kept him in a walled and open palatial mansion, but in a secret well-guarded dungeon where no one could have ever traced him. If any secret operative of ISI had knowledge of his presence in the suburbs of Abbottabad, he would have definitely informed some of his own kith to claim the fabulous reward. So to cast doubts on Pakistan’s intelligence agency that they knew about Osama’s presence in Abbottabad is a claim that does not hold water.

If ISI or the Pakistan’s military intelligence have failed due to what is being doled out as incompetence then such a stigma must also be shared by CIA and other premier intelligence agencies of the world which as well could not trace Osama. The Indian intelligence agency RAW would have definitely passed on that information to the United States to denigrate Pakistan.

One may imagine that a super power had remained obsessed with a terrorist who remained on the run and escaped for a decade from the most intensive manhunt recorded in history. That in these ten years the United States has killed an impressive number of Al-Qaida affiliates, speaks for the tenacity and frenzied propensity of  that country to punish the perpetrators of 9/11 incident that shook the world, changed the profile of America as well as the mentality and psyche of the American people. One of the baleful repercussions of the 9/11 tragedy was the steep hype in racial, ethnic and communal profiling of the immigrants especially of the Muslims.

One can also infer that the Afghanistan and Iraq wars that consumed millions of human beings, including tyrant Saddam Hussain was the consequence of the urge for routing the al-Qaida whose network previously had remained committed to the American cause of annihilating the Soviet Communist Empire. The al-Qaida under Osama’s leadership was in the vanguard of inflicting an historic defeat upon the Soviet Union, paving way for the rival United States to emerge as the sole super power.

The United States will not relent solely on killing Osama but would pursue with a new vigor to hunt down the remaining al-Qaida affiliates till this organization virtually become dysfunctional. So one can also perceive and speculate that United States would remain wedded to this course of chasing the living stalwarts of al-Qaida and kill them.

Pakistan, at present, looks like s subdued and shaking scapegoat.  She is confronted with the much speculated charge of betraying or playing a double game in America’s war against the al-Qaida terrorists who have been attacking American embassies and ship prior to the earth shaking attack on the World Trade Center in New York on November 11, 2001.

For all these years of chasing Osama and after his retreat from Tore Bora hideout, there were conflicting projections about Osama’s whereabouts. No one could be prepared to believe for a moment that he was still alive because of the widely believed perception that he might have died due to his serious kidney problems and non availiblity of complicated dialysis procedures to keep him alive.

The world had become complacent and rather forgetful that he was still a living, vibrant figure planning and masterminding further attacks on the United States. But while America remained safe from his destructive operations, Pakistan had suffered myriad suicide bombing and terrorist attacks that have wrecked the country economically and socially. Some of the attacks mostly coming from the radical Islamists from various religious groups may have been remotely maneuvered and directed by al-Qaida.

As long as Osama fought against the Soviet Union, he earned the kudos, blessings and full-fledged support from his mentors notably Pakistan and the United States. But when he started harboring the notions that he could defeat the United States in the same fashion as he defeated Soviet Union, he turned a villain and his erstwhile friends became his worst enemies.

Osama was not only a later day turned enemy of the United States but also of many Islamic countries including Saudi Arabia that he thought was sold out to American interests in the Middle East. He wanted American forces to be out from the Saudi Arabia. For him this was not only sacrilegious but provided bases to America to operate against the Islamic states in the region. He also believed that the presence of the American forces in Saudi Arabia, the cradle of Islam, would be detrimental to the economy of that country.

In the hindsight of his military exploits in Afghanistan that were achieved with the massive support from the United States, Pakistan and the western countries, Osama miscalculated that he could establish Islamic emirate in the Islamic countries and at the same time carry out attacks on American facilities all over the world. That was the beginning of his isolation and the dismal failure due to his self delusional ambitions.

He miscalculated American military and economic might and overestimated the capabilities of his rag tag outfit of followers that could only operate in a given area beefed up by the logistic backup, financial and weaponry support and with the planning of the established armies as was done in Afghanistan.

He chose the path of terrorizing and sabotage and clandestine suicide bombing through very motivated yet misguided members of Al-Qaida. The result is obvious as terrorism or violence is the least desired option for a genuine or even non-genuine cause to prevail or make any headway.

If he wanted to disseminate Islam, the best course for him was to mobilize his cohorts and followers to become the votaries of Islam and  preach the its pristine virtues with hallmarks such as justice, peace, equality,  accountability, human rights, piety, rectitude, morality and all the noble stuff that Islam offers.

Had he adopted this approach, he would have been still living and his mission and message going around the world without any antagonism, with great strides and glaring achievements He chose confrontation instead of pursuation and pleading.

The American media, taking undue advantage of the unbridled freedom of expression is relentlessly heaping scorn, dirt and innuendos on Pakistan that has been and is still an overly loyal and unwavering ally in American war on terrorism. The American press is trying to level unsubstantiated allegations against Pakistan for colluding with Osama and hiding him for presumably extracting monetary mileage out of Osama- fixated America.

While airing such uncharitable accusations against Pakistan, these commentators and analysts conveniently forget that Pakistani armed forces have been fighting in the most inhospitable terrain and against the most defiant fighters for the sake of America and NATO.

The unremitting military operation in the tribal regions between Pakistan and Afghanistan, against the Taliban and al-Qaida warriors is not a child’s play. The battling against a tenacious and religiously brainwashed enemy as Taliban is, the collateral damage has been colossal. Pakistan army alone has lost its valiant soldiers in thousands, besides many more maimed and injured.

Pakistan’s intelligence agencies have captured and handed over to the United States the bulk of al-Qaida top notch leaders that frustrated this organization’s functional network and paralyzed it administratively. As a result of these efforts, Pakistan was almost cleared of the covert Qaida activists. That was one conspicuous achievement alone should have been reciprocated by America with abiding gratitude.

Yet history repeats itself. Now when America is planning to retreat from Afghanistan and draw down its forces, the onus of not doing enough has fallen on Pakistan. If compared whether Pakistan has done marvelously well in the war against terrorism or NATO, the scale would heavily tilt towards Pakistan.

The Unite States used Pakistan and Muslim fighters from across the globe against Soviet Union in Afghanistan. After the victory, Americans left Pakistan and Afghanistan high and dry. In the follow up periods, Pakistan was almost being declared as a state sponsoring terrorism. Yet this false and made up charge was overturned when Pakistan was against needed after the 9/11 cataclysm. Pakistan is doing a thankless job that at the end of the day turns into a curse for it.

in the wake of the Osama’ end game episode, If the American Congressmen, Senators and the press alike are pleading stoppage or curtailing  Pakistan’s military aid punitively, then such a move would have corresponding adverse ramifications for the United States. Pakistan even without the American aid would survive. Nations do not prosper or die because of foreign alms or aid or its stoppage. Foreign aid with strings saps the independence of a country and Pakistan has experienced this anathema.

However, in that scenario, Pakistan would have no choice but to wind up its military operations in Waziristan and elsewhere. That would deal a fatal blow to the American and NATO ambitions and objectives in that dangerous terrain, with Taliban and even some left out al-Qaida fighters once again stalking the length and breadth of Afghanistan.

Let us not forget that Pakistan is paid because it allows its land for overland transport of all kind of merchandise for NATO forces. Moreover, Pakistan has to procure military hardware and pay to the soldiers fighting a terrible war. Wars are not gratis: these cause financial burdens.

The aid that is being given to Pakistan is a pittance of what Pakistan is doing in her northern regions. Pakistan has almost cleared these safe sanctuaries of the anti American militants. If Pakistan withdraws, these rugged valleys and inaccessible mountains would again become launching pads of forays for Taliban and other dreaded militants. How many drones American would send? It is the army that carries out straight combats and exterminates a much larger number of miscreants that what a thousand drones may not do if sent every day.

Finally let us not forget that Pakistan is a sovereign and independent state. It is not a protectorate, a hirling or vassal of the west or America. Its war efforts against the radical militants must be respected, acknowledged and highly applauded. If this blame game and diatribe against Pakistan does not stop, Pakistan should say adieu to the American aid and let the United States and NATO fight their own war. The candid corollary and the stark truth is that United States still needs Pakistan and needs indispensably.

The writer is a senior journalist and a former diplomat.

Advertisements
Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Comments

  • Bajwa  On May 10, 2011 at 12:53 am

    It is basically an issue of terms of engagement with various factions in this Fourth Anglo-Afghan war. It was wrong to get embroiled in this war. If we had too, the terms should have been clearly delineated. In the absence of that accusations and counter accusations were bound to arise.I don’t think the factions against Taliban ever coordinated their policies or actions.It was more like the spy thrillers where each one is free to act. OBL affair high lights this every one is accusing the other of bad faith.

    On top every one is fishing in the troubled water. Get this or that guy out.Gladly the civilian govt has behaved maturely,despite a flawed case.Mr Qureshi is right. ISI could hide OBL in a remote corner.No one has said that why they should do it.Are they keen to prolong American stay to get some money.. an amount which can be earned easily by better economic policies.Pakistan could earn more by trading with India, for instance or opening up the services sectors, particularly food services.

    • Amir Rana  On May 10, 2011 at 12:54 am

      It has happened since last 1000 years and will keep on happening for another 1000 years that we, the Muslims, refuse to see the things in right perspective. Whatever analysis we perform after getting betrayed, either in short run or in the longer one, is nothing but an aftermath being put on the intellectual dining table. One should never keep religion aside while analyzing any conflict in which Muslims are involved. Islam is a religion in which as per Allah (SWT), one is either 100% in or 100% out. One cannot pick and choose certain virtues and ignore certain guidelines or duties mentioned in Quran. The rules of game are clearly mentioned times and again in the Holy Book.

      Any careful observer of history would come to the conclusion that Muslims have never gained any long term advantage whenever they have tried to be on the side of non-muslims against their own brothers. Did the supporters of crusaders get anything when they joined hands against Salahuddin Ayubi? Could the last rulers save Spain by negotiating peace treaties with Ferdinend? Did Arabs get something positive out of their being on the side of Lawrance of Arabia? Was Nizam of Hyderabad right when he chose to be on British side against Tipu? Was the decision of Mughals to let East India Company grow and hold strategic position in Subcontinent correct even in a pure political perspective? AND for that matter, has Pakistan gained something substancial by being on US side since its coming into being??? No matter what these sold out rulers or Army elite does for them, we, as a whole would be on the losing side. Only gainers amongst us are the first and second hand agents working to protect the interests of their MASTER.

      Allah has clearly said in Quran that these non-muslims can never be our friends. Living in peace in short run is something else but in longer run there will always be situations in which these two sides have to be in direct confrontation. This is a war between right and wrong and will continue till the last day of this world. There is a whole pattern of life in Quran for Muslims. It is not limited to some rituals at individual level. Moreover, a lot of things have to be seen in perspective of the concept of Judgment Day and Life after death. The material with which an Islamic system is constructed is very different from hardcore socio-political concepts we are normally used to. As Iqbal says; KHAAS HAI TARKEEB MAIN QAUM-E-RASOOL-E-HASHMI. He was the person who understood what this religion really is. He formed his opinion after getting through the high and low tides of this world. He was neither a tunnel-visioned Mullah nor a pseudo-intellectual. One needs very little time to understand what he proposed as prescription for this ailing Ummah. His first and foremost stress was on self-recognition, self-respect, self-dependence and courage to take a stand. Unfortunately these are the elements we seriously lack today.

      Those who think there would be Global Peace if Muslims stop Jihaad are living in fool’s paradise. The concept of Global Peace is a myth. It was never there and it will never be there. Can somebody prove me wrong by quoting even a period of 100 years which could be categorized as war free? We, the humans are simply not created in that manner. There can be a balanced competition (normally resulting in cold war situation) but if someone thinks there will be none, would be on the wrong track of thought process. Fact of the matter is that majority of Muslims neither understand the concept of Jihaad nor is ready to be a part of it. We are in a ditch not because of Jihaad but due to lack of it.

      Survival of the fittest is the universal rule here. However, the definition of “Fitness” is altogether another dimension. Here again, the rules have been defined very clearly in Quran and Ahadees. For Muslims to be amongst the fittest, the first and foremost criteria is to have undoubted faith in Allah and self-recognition. It is then the duty of every Muslim to be always prepared for competition. Resources, and the comparison of material power is secondary for us. History has sufficient proof of it. Muslims came out as victorious on a number of occasions despite having no comparison on technological and economic fronts. On the other hand they themselves were destroyed in Spain and Baghdad by forces much less in strength.

      History keeps itself repeating, but unfortunately majority of our think-tanks and intellectuals refuse to read what is clearly written on the wall. I don’t know why we like to sit on the round table, beleaguered and thwarted, after getting betrayed by our friend shaped enemies, licking our wounds and complaining the unjust treatment we get. It is the same treatment we got several times in history but we never seem to learn our lesson.

  • Javaid Haider  On May 10, 2011 at 12:54 am

    they have been trying to get to OBL for over a decade. they have spent in trillions of dollars trying to get to him. then, when they get to him they killed him?! i don’t believe that. they probably captured him and making him talk. when they have got suficient info. they will probably kill him. i feel sorry for generals kiyani and shuja pasha. i think they should resign. the army must stop interfering in civilian matters and just focus on its professional duties. it should get away from commercialism which it is currently pursuing with vigour. askari bank, real estate, fauji foundation etc. having said that, i also cannot help thinking that DG ISI was in america 10 days ago prompting chaudhry nisar of PML-N to state that he tell parliament about discussions he held in washington. a day after his return, general patreus arrived in islamabad to hold a one on one talks with gen. kiyani. a day or two later, the drama in abbotabad takes place. AAJ tv interviewed the neighbours and they said that an before the raid, pakistani soldiers had told them not to switch on lights nor come out of their houses. this report was not repeated. further, the army said that the americans had jammed the radar and the helicopters were hugging close to the terrain, thus able to evade the radar. but, if the radars are jammed, there is no need to hug the terrain. further, the air chief says radars were not jammed, that the airforce was tracking the helicopters, that sources say two F-16s were circling overhead as the raid was taking place, but were told not to interfere and return to the base.

    poor pakistanis will never know the truth.

  • Nadeem  On May 10, 2011 at 3:47 am

    Thank you, Mr Saeed Qureshi, for standing up for our motherland in a time when it is being blamed and ridiculed from all quarters. You have written the plain truth, which is highly commendable.

    NK

  • Ernest Frank  On May 10, 2011 at 3:55 am

    If ISI or the Pakistan’s military intelligence have failed due to what is being doled out as incompetence then such a stigma must also be shared by CIA and other premier intelligence agencies of the world which as well could not trace Osama.

    Yes. This is all the faulty of the CIA. After all, Bin Laden was living within 2 miles of West Point and the CIA missed him. (Or, more ominously, knew all about him and allowed him to live there.)

    Oh, wait. You must have meant ISI.

  • Adeel  On May 11, 2011 at 4:06 pm

    I think what is important to consider now is why this whole drama was enacted, and what is the likely aim of our longtime ally, the US, whom we should have walked away from long ago.
    The damage done to the services, specifically the army and the intelligence services is tremendous. There are many who gloat over this, not knowing that they axe themselves when they do so.
    I think this is a golden opportunity to rid ourselves of this burden and we can only do it if we can get over our lust for $$.

    The lead needs to be taken by the Services.

    Adeel

  • ID  On May 12, 2011 at 1:11 am

    I think it is a useless piece and such pieces have landed us in the situation we are today. The US fooled us into the war in Afghanistan, and remember, it was a civil war, just as in Libya today. We became directly involved over extending ourselves in the hubris of dollars and fighting Communism as if kufr was worse than Mushriks. SO much for jehaad then and so much for Anti-Americanism now. Why don;t we see that “Our Slip Is Showing?” We continue in the sam selfdenial and selfcongratulatory mould. The paradox has played out, but we still want to retain it. Dvelop character so that we are able to identify ourself and say, “This is us!”
    idrees

  • Kristle Macivor  On May 15, 2011 at 1:49 am

    Amazing! Your article has quite a few comments. How did you get so many viewers to view your post I’m envious! I’m still learning all about blogs on the web. I’m going to look around on your website to get a better understanding how to achieve success. Thanks for the assistance!

  • callaway x-20 review  On May 22, 2011 at 1:05 pm

    Hello There. I found your blog the usage of msn. That is a really well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to learn extra of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely comeback.

  • fat burning furnace  On May 25, 2011 at 11:00 am

    Simply a smiling visitor here to share the love (:, btw outstanding design.

  • last minute bungalow  On May 25, 2011 at 7:38 pm

    Great goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely wonderful. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it wise. I cant wait to read far more from you. This is actually a terrific site.

  • White iphone 4 release date  On June 3, 2011 at 10:46 pm

    This is a honestly well thought out site utilizing some rather valuable facts that at least makes individuals think when they read it. I visit lots of blogs each and every week and this 1 appears to have truly be done especially well with the reader at the foremost of the blog owner. Wonderful job

  • This is a honestly well thought out blog having some quite practical facts that at least makes people think when they read it. I view a number of blogs each and every week and this 1 appears to have actually be done really well with the reader at the foremost of the blog owner. Fantastic job

  • nikon digital camera lens  On June 7, 2011 at 10:29 am

    This is a truly well thought out blog with some really useful facts which at least makes people think when they read it. I view a number of blogs every single week and this 1 seems to have actually be done very well with the reader at the foremost of the blog owner. Perfect job

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: